1. Lack of Scientific Evidence

Mainstream astronomers and astrophysicists have found no credible evidence for the existence of a planetary body as described by Broussard:

  • The movement of celestial bodies, including planets and dwarf planets, is meticulously tracked by institutions like NASA. A planet with the alleged size and trajectory of "Planet 7X" would have been detected by telescopes, gravitational anomalies, or infrared surveys.
  • Broussard relies heavily on anecdotal and unverified interpretations of historical events rather than observable astronomical data.

2. Misinterpretation of Biblical Texts

Broussard attempts to link "Planet 7X" to biblical catastrophes, such as Noah's Flood or the plagues of Egypt. However:

  • Biblical events are often symbolic or metaphorical and not meant to be literal historical or astronomical accounts.
  • Scholars argue that forcing astronomical explanations onto these stories misrepresents their cultural and spiritual context.

3. Orbital Mechanics Don't Add Up

Planet 7X is alleged to have an orbit that brings it close to Earth every few hundred years. If true:

  • Its gravitational effects would have disrupted the orbits of other planets in the solar system, leaving a clear and ongoing record in orbital paths and dynamics.
  • No such disruptions have been observed or recorded in modern astronomy or historical celestial data.

4. Lack of Peer Review

Broussard's work has not been published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, a key standard for validating scientific claims. Instead, it relies on self-published books and presentations, which lack the rigorous scrutiny of the scientific community.

5. Cognitive Bias and Fear Appeals

Conspiracy theories like Planet 7X often thrive on fear and uncertainty:

  • By tying his theory to apocalyptic scenarios, Broussard taps into primal fears and creates a sense of urgency.
  • People are more likely to believe extraordinary claims when tied to catastrophic consequences, even in the absence of evidence.

Conclusion

The "Planet 7X" theory is not supported by scientific evidence, peer-reviewed research, or credible astronomical observation. It is a speculative narrative that relies on unverified interpretations of historical and religious texts. While intriguing as a piece of speculative fiction, it should not be regarded as a legitimate scientific theory.